If It’s Not Working, It’s Time to Tweak: Why Stubbornness Isn’t Strategy

Oct 28, 2023 · Pesa Shayo · 6 min read

Introduction

There’s something honorable about sticking with it. But if your efforts are creating more tension than closeness, it’s time to reassess. In this post, we talk about the courage it takes to admit when a tactic isn’t working-and the wisdom to tweak, adapt, and try a new route toward the same destination: connection.

Too often, couples confuse stubborn persistence with dedication. While commitment is key to a thriving marriage, rigidity can quietly erode intimacy. You’re not giving up when you change your approach. You’re giving your marriage a better chance to breathe, connect, and grow. Let’s explore how letting go of a failing strategy isn’t failure-it’s wisdom in action.

 

Ready to identify your next best step?

The United Front Audit gives you a personalized picture of what needs work - and a clear path forward as a couple.

Take the Audit - It's Free →

When Persistence Turns into Stubbornness

There’s a fine line between being committed and being inflexible. Many spouses think, “I’m doing what the book said,” or “I’ve been consistent, so why isn’t this working-” But when your partner doesn’t respond positively, repeating the same thing won’t suddenly make it effective.

Married couple feeling distant after repetitive effort in communicationIf your weekly date night feels like a chore, your “I love you” texts sound like autopilot, or your efforts to talk lead to tension-then it’s time to tweak. Not because the goal is wrong, but because the method has run its course.

Rigid effort isn’t romance. It’s repetition without results. And if it’s not working, it’s not weakness to pivot-it’s wisdom.

 

Tweak the Strategy, Not the Commitment

Let’s be clear: tweaking doesn’t mean quitting. It means honoring the commitment by changing how you live it out.

Marriage metaphor of tweaking strategy like rerouting GPS to reach connectionJust as you’d reroute when your GPS finds traffic ahead, in marriage, the goal stays the same-connection, closeness, growth-but the route might need adjusting.

Ask yourself:

  • Are my current habits producing connection or just obligation-
  • Is my partner responding with warmth or withdrawal-
  • Am I willing to change how I show love if it brings us closer-

These aren’t signs of giving up. They’re signs that you care enough to find a better way.

 

Recognizing the Signs That It’s Not Working

It’s tempting to think: “If I keep at it, they’ll come around.” But marriage isn’t about enduring your spouse-it’s about engaging them.

Here are common signs that your strategy needs tweaking:

  • Silence or short answers during your attempts to connect
  • Arguments sparked by what’s supposed to be quality time
  • Affection that feels one-sided or unreciprocated
  • Consistent effort met with indifference or tension

Marriage schedule showing ineffective repeated habits that need rethinkingWhen patterns lead to distance, not closeness, it’s time to stop doubling down and start rethinking.

 

Why Stubbornness Isn’t Strategy in Marriage

Persistence is great-for marathons, projects, and saving money. But in relationships, rigidity without responsiveness is the enemy of intimacy.

Imagine trying to use a single key for every lock. Eventually, you’ll encounter a door it won’t open. The problem isn’t your effort-it’s the mismatch between your strategy and what your partner actually needs.

Symbol of stubborn approach in marriage that no longer opens emotional connectionLove requires listening-not just to words, but to emotional reactions, body language, and tone. If what you’re doing isn’t unlocking closeness, change the key.

 

Discover what's fueling tension in your marriage

It's rarely just one thing. The United Front Audit maps the pressure points so you know exactly where to focus.

See Your Results →

Real Love Is Willing to Adjust

Some people worry that adjusting their approach means losing authenticity. But the most genuine love is flexible-not fake.

Your spouse isn’t asking you to be someone else. They’re asking to be understood.

Spouse attentively listening to understand partner’s needs in marriageThat might mean learning a new love language, changing your tone, or showing affection in a different way than you’re used to. Adaptation isn’t weakness. It’s love in motion.

 

Examples of Tweaking in Real Marriages

The Over-Planner and the Free Spirit
He planned every weekend outing. She felt smothered. After one too many awkward Saturdays, they agreed to alternate weekends-one planned, one spontaneous.

The Affection Disconnect
She gave hugs constantly. He barely responded. Turns out, he needed verbal affirmation more than touch. She adjusted her approach to say what she felt instead of only showing it physically.

The Scheduled Conversations
He tried to have deep talks before bed. She was too exhausted. They switched to Sunday morning coffee chats instead-and it transformed their connection.

Real-life example of adapting connection style for stronger marriage momentsNone of these couples gave up on connection. They gave up on what wasn’t working.

 

The Fear of “Giving In” vs. Growing Together

There’s a hidden fear behind stubbornness: “If I change, I lose control. I lose the high ground.”

But marriage isn’t a battleground. You don’t win by staying the same. You win by growing together.

Married couple agreeing to grow together by adjusting their approachReal maturity says: I care more about what works for us than proving I’m right.

If your current strategy feels like a power struggle or a stalemate, you’re not losing by changing-you’re choosing peace.

 

The Power of Asking a Better Question

Instead of saying, “Why isn’t this working-”, ask:

  • “What might work better-”
  • “How does my spouse best feel loved-”
  • “What have we outgrown-and what could replace it-”

Changing the questions you ask changes the way you engage.

Marriage journal with questions for self-reflection and connectionYou’ll move from frustration to curiosity-and that opens new doors for intimacy.

 

Don’t Wait for Crisis to Make the Shift

Too many couples wait until resentment builds before tweaking their approach. But you don’t need to be on the brink to make change.

Early signs of disconnect in marriage before major breakdown occursStart small. Adjust one habit. Change the timing of a conversation. Modify how you show love.

These little shifts send a big message: I see you. I care enough to try again.

 

Not sure what's really going wrong?

The United Front Audit helps you pinpoint exactly where your marriage unity is breaking down - in just 3 minutes.

Take the Free Audit →

What Tweaking Might Look Like This Week

  • Instead of forcing long conversations at night, send a thoughtful voice memo during the day.
  • Instead of planning a big gesture, try a spontaneous compliment or small act of service.
  • Instead of defaulting to what’s routine, ask: “Would you like to do something different this week-”
  • Instead of assuming your way is the only way, ask your spouse how they feel about your efforts.

Spouses collaborating to adjust and personalize connection in marriageThe goal is not to abandon what matters. It’s to arrive at connection through whatever road works best now.

 

Stubbornness Is Comfortable-But It’s Not Loving

Doing what you’ve always done feels safe. But comfort is not the same as closeness.

When your spouse’s needs change, or when life evolves, your approach needs to grow too.

Emotional distance in marriage caused by unyielding patternsLove that listens adjusts. Love that values peace over pride adapts.

And love that’s willing to tweak-even when it’s uncomfortable-is love that lasts.

 

Tweak Today, Thrive Tomorrow

Marriage is full of seasons. What worked in year one might fail in year five. That’s not a problem-it’s an invitation.

Tweaking your approach keeps your marriage alive. It allows you to keep discovering each other. It says, “I’m still paying attention.”

Married couple adjusting to new season with shared care and flexibilitySo if what you’re doing right now isn’t working, don’t see that as failure. See it as feedback.

And then-with love and courage-try something new.

 

Action Steps to Tweak Your Approach This Week

  1. Have an honest check-in – Ask: “How are we doing emotionally, really-”
  2. Pick one area that feels off – Is it communication- Time together- Affection-
  3. Ask for input – “What would feel better or more meaningful to you-”
  4. Try a new method – Even just one. A new date format, a new tone, a new question.
  5. Reflect and repeat – What worked- What didn’t- Stay flexible.

Your marriage is worth the effort-and worth doing differently if needed.

Pesa Shayo Shayo

Get to Know

Pesa Shayo

Pesa Shayo is a husband, father and author.

As the co-founder of Live Your Best Marriage, Pesa brings a blend of practical and easy-to-follow steps rooted in Biblical principles to his guidance.

He's been happily married for over 22 years and devotes a great deal of time to his children.

Pesa enjoys going for hikes with his family.

Take the United Front Audit →

Keep Reading

See what to fix first

The United Front Audit gives you clarity on where your marriage unity is breaking down – and a personalized path forward.

Take the Audit – It's Free